top of page

When the Body You Recovered in Isn’t the Body You Have Anymore

Writer: Dianna Chillo, LCSW-R
Dianna Chillo, LCSW-R
4 days ago
11 min read

I grew up Gen X, which means I grew up in the thick of 90s and early

2000s diet culture. Magazines at the grocery store checkout counter promised you could lose ten pounds by summer, sitting right next to cover stories about

dangerously thin celebrities. The contradiction was apparently lost on

everyone.


It was incredibly harmful and it influenced how an entire generation of girls

learned to see their bodies. But there was something different about diet

culture back then. It had an off switch. Back then, you could pick up the

magazine, or you could put it down and walk out of the store.

I don’t think we acknowledge or talk enough about how much that choice

mattered.


In 2015, I experienced a devastating relapse in my own eating disorder. If

there’s anything fortunate about a relapse, I suppose I was fortunate in the

timing of my recovery. Body positivity was beginning to gain momentum.

Body diversity was becoming more visible, and conversations about body

acceptance was finally happening.


That didn’t make recovery easy, not in the slightest. But as I worked toward

accepting a body that looked different from the one, I had been so

desperately trying to maintain, the world seemed to be making a little more

room for that to be possible.


Fast-forward ten years, and here we are again. Except, in many ways, it’s

worse.


GLP-1 medications are everywhere. Weight loss is being celebrated,

repackaged, and sold to us under the guise of wellness and longevity.

Social media has replaced the magazines we once picked up at the

checkout counter. Except now, we can’t simply put them down and walk

away. We are inundated with these messages everywhere.


I am also 10 years older and over the last several years, I’ve navigated

perimenopause and now menopause. And let me tell you, this has not been

an easy transition.


My body has changed, my hormones have changed, and there are days

when I genuinely feel like I woke up in a body I don’t recognize. And while I

understand that these changes are a normal part of aging, understanding

something intellectually and being comfortable with it emotionally are two

very different things.


To make matters worse, because I’m a woman in midlife, my social media

feed seems to have decided that I need fixing.


From the moment I open up any one of my social media accounts, all I see

is how to eat in menopause, how to exercise in menopause, how to lose

the menopause belly, how to reverse aging, what supplements to take,

what foods to avoid, how much protein I need, am I eating too much, am I

eating too little, what workouts I should be doing and the list goes on and

on.


Apparently, simply existing as a woman 50 and over is now a problem that

requires another product, program, or promise waiting to “fix” you, for a

monthly subscription, of course! It’s exhausting and incredibly stressful.

But here’s the part I want to be really transparent about.


Ten years into recovery, and here I am, struggling with body image

again.


I don’t want to return to my eating disorder; I absolutely do not. But

because the body I worked so hard to recover into, the body I eventually

learned to accept, feed, dress, and live in, has changed again, and feels

like it keeps changing.


I had built a relationship with my recovered body. I ate, drank, socialized

and bought clothes that fit. I stopped allowing food and my body to dictate

how I lived my life. I was good.


Then midlife arrived, and suddenly I found myself having to navigate an

entirely new relationship with my body.


I choose not to weigh myself and I typically ask not to be weighed at doctor

appointments. But during a medical appointment where taking my weight

was insisted upon, I became aware that my weight had shifted. I’m not

sharing numbers because they’re irrelevant to the point I’m making.

What matters is that I know my body has changed. I feel it in my clothes,

see it in the mirror, and some days, I really struggle with it. And yes,

sometimes I get angry.


I get frustrated that we’re living in a culture where changing your body has

become so normalized that it almost feels like you’re the exception if you’re

not actively trying to do something about it.


I see people around me using GLP-1 medications, celebrating weight loss,

talking about how much better they feel in smaller bodies. And I want to be

very clear: I respect body autonomy. I believe people have the right to

make informed decisions about their own health and their own bodies.

I also have concerns about these medications that go beyond my eating

disorder history. There are aspects about these medications that make me

uncomfortable, and I’m not entirely sure I’d choose to take one even if I

didn’t have that history.

But here’s where the frustration gets personal.


For me, pursuing weight loss through a medication like this isn’t simply

another option to consider. It’s a door I know I cannot safely open. And

sometimes, that makes me angry.

Not because I want to return to restricting or obsessing over my weight. Not

because I believe a smaller body would somehow make my life better. I

know where that thinking leads.


But because I am human and menopause has been difficult. Because there

are days when I feel uncomfortable in my body and wish there were an

easy answer. And because everywhere I look, someone seems to be

offering one.


That’s a difficult thing to sit with, even when you know better. Even when I

know it’s normal for our bodies to change with age.

Even when you’re the therapist helping other people navigate these exact

feelings.


I’ve spent a lot of time over the last several years trying to understand

what’s underneath my own discomfort.

Because here’s what I know, both professionally and personally: body

image struggles are rarely just about the body. These feelings are information for me to get curious about.


Over these last several years, I’ve experienced significant life changes,

transitions, and uncertainty. And uncertainty can feel incredibly

uncomfortable. When life feels unpredictable, the idea of controlling

something, even something as seemingly simple as our food or our bodies,

can become very appealing.


Eating disorders are particularly good at selling us that illusion.

They promise control and safety when, in reality, they take it away.

I know this because I’ve lived it.


And I know that no amount of weight loss, no number on a scale, and no

change in my clothing size will resolve the things in my life that actually

need my attention.


That doesn’t mean the desire to change my body magically disappears. It

means I have to recognize it for what it is.


I have to remind myself that discomfort is not an emergency. That a

changing body is not a personal failure. And that I don’t have to act on

every uncomfortable feeling I experience.


This is something I talk about with my clients all the time.

We live in a world where behaviors that can be incredibly dangerous for

someone with an eating disorder history are not only normalized but

celebrated.


Call it a lifestyle change, a wellness journey, or whatever the latest trendy

term happens to be. For someone vulnerable to an eating disorder, the

behaviors connected to many of these trends can become a very slippery

slope.


And recovery doesn’t make us immune. I am living proof. After almost 20

years in recovery, I chose to participate in something that is widely

accepted and promoted to promote health. Due to physical issues I was

having, I thought this would be a good idea. At the time, I believed I was

doing something positive for myself. What I didn’t recognize was how

vulnerable it would leave me and awaken something I thought was long

gone.


It wasn’t the sole cause of my relapse. As in most cases, there were many

other contributing factors happening in my life. But it became the tipping

point that sent me down a road I never imagined I’d find myself on again.

So, ten years, twenty years, or more into recovery, vulnerability can still

exist.


This is why I am such a strong advocate for my clients, particularly those

who are being encouraged to pursue weight loss or are considering GLP-1

medications because they believe changing their bodies will resolve their

discomfort or even “cure” their eating disorder.


These medications have legitimate medical uses, and decisions about

them deserve individualized, thoughtful conversations with qualified

providers. An eating disorder history does not automatically mean the same

medical decision is appropriate for everyone.

But we cannot ignore the psychological risks, particularly when someone is

already struggling with food, weight, or body image.


I’ve seen how quickly the promise of changing a body can overshadow the

work of learning to live in it.

And I know how seductive that promise can be.


There is something especially painful about watching a culture celebrate

behaviors that, for some of us, could unravel years of recovery.


Sometimes protecting your recovery means choosing not to participate in

something the rest of the world seems to be celebrating.

And that can feel unfair and, I think we need to make room to acknowledge

that without shame.


Lately, I’ve been seeing more women in my practice navigating these same

struggles. Women in perimenopause and menopause, women with eating

disorder histories, women currently struggling with eating disorders, and

women who may never have had a diagnosis but have spent much of their

lives feeling at war with their bodies.


And while everyone’s experience is different, there’s a common thread.

These women are uncomfortable, frustrated and they’re being told there’s

something they should be doing to fix it. And many are exhausted from

trying.


I don’t believe the answer is telling women they need to love their bodies

every single day. I honestly think that can become another unrealistic

expectation.

Some days, body acceptance feels possible. Other days, body neutrality

may be the best we can do. And that’s okay.


What I encourage my clients to practice, and what I continue to practice

myself, is curiosity instead of judgment.

When I find myself wanting to change my body, I try to get curious about

that feeling.


What’s happening in my life right now? What am I uncomfortable with? Am

I looking for a sense of control? Am I comparing myself to someone else?

Am I believing that changing my body will somehow change how I feel

about myself or my life?


And perhaps most importantly, what would pursuing that change actually

cost me?


Because for someone with an eating disorder history, it’s important to be

honest about how easily the language of health and wellness can become

a way to justify returning to old behaviors. Not every desire to improve our

health is rooted in an eating disorder. But not every behavior marketed as

healthy is necessarily healthy for us, either.


Sometimes the work is learning to sit with discomfort rather than

immediately trying to fix it.

And sometimes, the work is allowing yourself to be really freaking

frustrated. It’s also about acknowledging that we live in a culture that is

reinforcing these feelings and beliefs.


Sometimes you need to throw a little tantrum and allow yourself to cry

about it. Find someone you trust that you can vent to. Discuss your feelings

in therapy or simply acknowledge how unfair and uncomfortable it all feels.

Not every difficult feeling needs to be analyzed or immediately turned into

something positive. Sometimes we just need to let ourselves feel it. There’s

something incredibly cathartic about being able to say, “I hate how this

feels right now,” without judging yourself for feeling that way.


You can be frustrated with your body without punishing it. You can

wish things were different without resorting to old behaviors. And you

can respect your body even on the days you’re struggling to accept it.


Those feelings are allowed to exist. They don’t have to dictate what you do

next.


I’ve also become much more intentional about what I allow into my social

media feed.

If an account consistently leaves me feeling inadequate, ashamed, or like I

need to change something about myself, I unfollow it. I don’t care how

many followers that person has or how convincing their message sounds.


I’m not interested in spending my time consuming content that makes me

feel like my body is a problem that needs solving.

Instead, I seek out people who talk about recovery, aging, body

acceptance, and wellness without making weight loss the ultimate goal. I

also follow accounts that are fun and appeal to my interests outside of

anything that has to do with any of this.


Does that eliminate the messaging entirely? Of course not. But it gives me

some control over what I’m choosing to consume.

And sometimes, the work is a different kind of retail therapy;

Sometimes it’s buying the bigger pants.

Finding clothes that feel comfortable. Changing my style. Letting go of

something that no longer fits instead of keeping it in my closet as a

reminder of a body I used to have.


And yes, sometimes that brings up feelings, too.

I haven’t mastered any of this. I’m still figuring it out.

But what I do know is that I don’t want to spend the next chapter of my life

fighting my body.



I love food, I love cooking, I love trying new restaurants, sharing meals, and

bringing people together around a table.

Food has always been so much more to me than nutrition. It’s connection,

tradition and pleasure. It’s part of how we celebrate and experience life.

And I worked too damn hard to get that back.


I refuse to sacrifice those experiences in pursuit of a body that may no

longer be realistic for me, or one that was never meant to remain

unchanged in the first place.


That doesn’t mean I’m never going to feel frustrated again.

It doesn’t mean I won’t have days when I look in the mirror and wish

something were different.

But I can experience those feelings without allowing them to dictate my

choices.


I can acknowledge that menopause has been difficult without treating my

body as something that has failed me.

And I can be an eating disorder therapist who advocates fiercely for

recovery while still being a woman navigating her own complicated feelings

about aging and body image.

Those things can coexist.


Ten years ago, when I was in the depths of my relapse, I didn’t know if I’d

ever get my life back. But I did.


And I refuse to let a culture obsessed with shrinking bodies convince me

that the life I’ve built in recovery is somehow less valuable because my

body has changed.

I may have to learn to accept my body again, in a different season of life,

under different circumstances.


This is something I talk about with my clients all the time, particularly those

who are terrified of weight gain as part of eating disorder recovery.

I remind them that our bodies were never meant to remain the same

throughout our lives.


We may settle into a body that feels familiar for years, sometimes decades.

We learn to dress it, feed it, move in it, and hopefully become more

comfortable living in it.


But life happens. We age, we get wrinkles, our hormones change. We

experience pregnancy, menopause, illness, stress, and countless other

transitions that can change our bodies in ways we never anticipated.


And sometimes, just when we’ve finally made peace with one version of

ourselves, we find ourselves having to do that work all over again.


That’s why recovery can’t be about learning to accept your body only

when it reaches a certain weight, size, or shape. Because what

happens when that body inevitably changes?


The real work is learning to build a relationship with our bodies that can

withstand those changes. One rooted in respect, flexibility, and compassion

rather than a particular number or appearance.


That doesn’t mean we have to welcome every change with open arms. It

means recognizing that our bodies deserve care and respect through every

season of life, including the ones we find most difficult. And maybe that’s

something we don’t talk about enough.


Recovery isn’t about learning to love one version of your body and

hoping it never changes. It’s about learning how to keep showing up

for yourself as it does.

If you’re navigating this too, whether you’re in eating disorder recovery,

going through menopause, or simply trying to make peace with a body that

no longer looks or feels the way it once did, I see you and I hope you’ll give

yourself some grace. You don’t have to love every change. You don’t have

to pretend it isn’t hard.


But you deserve a life that is bigger than the pursuit of a smaller body.


And so, do I.


Dianna Chillo-Havercamp, LCSW-R, is a psychotherapist specializing in

eating disorders, body image, and related mental health concerns. To learn

more about her practice and available services, visit www.diannachillo.com⁠.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page